Getting Fast Thinkers to Slow Down
Talking students through how the brain worksâits shortcuts and tendency to draw incorrect conclusions based on limited informationâcan help them study and learn better.
Your content has been saved!
Go to My Saved Content.Try solving this simple problem with your students: A bat and a ball together cost $1.10. The bat costs a dollar more than the ball. How much does the ball cost?
Most will respond quickly that the ball must cost 10 cents. Thatâs incorrect. The ball costs 5 cents.
âWe know a significant fact about anyone who says that the ball costs 10 cents,â writes Nobel Prizeâwinning psychologist Daniel Kahneman in his seminal 2011 book, Thinking, Fast and Slow. âThat person did not actively check whether the answer was correct.â We also know they relied on instinct to rapidly deliver an answerâwhat Kahneman calls fast thinking.
At any given moment, our brains encounter an immense amount of stimuli to which we react intuitivelyâlike deciding in an instant if someoneâs tone denotes anger or confusion, or quickly understanding simple sentences as we read. These are near-automatic thought processes that require very little effort.
This type of instinctive, reactive thinking is essential for survival, but an overreliance on fast thinking can also lead to errors and bias, Kahneman contends. Slow thinking, by contrast, is analytical and deliberate, like when students raise their hand instead of impulsively calling out an answer, or they pause to solve a math problem that requires some degree of computational work, like 15 x 42.
But overconfidence has a tendency to creep in during learning, tricking students into believing that their first reflexive response is correct. Our brains have to work harder and expend more energy to think slowly, one of the main reasons that fast thinking can become a go-to cognitive reflex. In the rush to answer a question or solve a problem, fast thinking can lead students astray, causing them to reach conclusions based on incomplete information or make snap judgments influenced by cognitive bias.
Teaching students how the brain is wired for decision-making is an important part of creating conscious learners who can develop nuanced opinions and make smart, informed choices, says Renee Hobbs, a researcher and professor of communication studies at the University of Rhode Island. Educators can help students learn how to navigate the cognitive tricks our minds can play on us while instilling a sense of intellectual humilityâan underemphasized life skill that combats overconfidence and encourages curiosity and vigilance when faced with new information or uncertainty. âThat awareness propels intellectual curiosity while also leaving them with an appreciation for what they donât know,â Hobbs says.
Here are four strategies to help students understand the benefits of slowing down their thinking:
Identify stealthy brain tricks: Despite having limited knowledge of a subject, kids often trick themselves into âa tendency known as the Dunning-Kruger effect. Studentsâ first instincts about what they do or donât know are often wrong: guessing that the ball cost 10 cents without slowing down to check their work, for instance. The problem is, on top of being incorrect, the mind tricks them into feeling confident that they are right.
Before exams, Woo-Kyoung Ahn, a psychology professor at Yale University, directs her students to explain aloud concepts theyâve learned to a friend or family member, as if the other person has never encountered this information. That process of explanation can open studentsâ eyes to what they know and what they donât, Ahn says.
âIn an experiment, researchers asked, âDo you know how a toilet works, how a helicopter works?â and so on. Of course, subjects canât build one from scratch, but they know thereâs a propeller at the top,â she explains. Still, the subjects respond affirmatively and provide a brief description. Next, theyâre asked to write out a detailed explanation of how these things actually workâit can be quite clarifying. âThatâs enough for them to realize they didnât quite understand what they thought they did,â Ahn says.
Before an exam, students may feel like they understand all the materials because they skimmed their notes and highlighted key terms, but when theyâre asked to articulate exactly what they claim to know, they come up short.
Making students aware of the Dunning-Kruger effectâin addition to creating more opportunities for students to actively demonstrate their learning and incorporating occasional checks for understanding throughout the unitâprovides kids with a more nuanced view of what they know, as well as what they only sort of know or donât know at all. This identifies areas they should slow down and target, before and during test prep.
Connect to studentsâ own lives: Being able to recognize examples of cognitive bias in their own lives, Hobbs says, puts students on a path toward making better, more strategic choices.
Instead of providing examples from your own adult life, Hobbs suggests, have kids come up with examples of cognitive biasâdigital amnesia, in-group favoritism, and authority bias, for exampleââfrom their own lives and write those down as stories,â she says. "Those are going to be super-powerful for helping students build that awareness where they understand âHereâs how my brain is biased to work, and hereâs how I experience that in daily life.ââ
Middle school history teacher Jordan Mattox uses the Gulf of Tonkin incident to illustrate real-world confirmation bias, the propensity of people to seek out information or evidence that confirms their own opinions, beliefs, and values. âThe lesson guides students through how President Johnson looked for a way to justify his invasion plans,â Mattox writes. âStudents connect Johnsonâs actions to modern examples of confirmation bias by looking at Russian involvement in the 2016 election through social media.â Students are then encouraged to reflect on how confirmation bias can, and has, affected them while using social media.
Instill healthy skepticism: Teaching students to exercise a degree of caution when approaching new information onlineâinstead of accepting everything they read as factâis important, explains Julie Coiro, an associate professor of education at the University of Rhode Island. To strengthen her studentsâ abilities to critically analyze and parse information during online research before jumping to quick conclusions, Coiro asks them to consider the following prompts:
- What is the purpose of this site?
- Who created the information at this site, and what is this personâs level of expertise?
- Where can I go to check the accuracy of this information?
- Why did this person or group put this information on the internet?
In addition to explaining the concept of echo chambersâan environment where a person solely encounters information or perspectives that mirror and support their ownâand the power they have to perpetuate misinformation and warp peopleâs perspective, middle school history teacher Chris Orlando suggests that students slow down and ask the following questions when consuming information:
- Does the source give only one perspective of an issue?
- Is that perspective primarily supported by rumor or partial evidence?
- Are facts ignored whenever they oppose that viewpoint?
Hold each other accountable: Peopleânot just kidsâhave a tendency to forget where they learned something as soon as they learn it, which is known in psychology as source monitoring bias. âWe stumble upon a piece of media content, take it in, and completely forget where we got it from,â Hobbs explains. âThen we come up with an idea and we think itâs our own, but weâve just forgotten where we read it the first time.â
In our media-saturated culture, this has serious negative impacts, and in the classroom it can even lead to inadvertent plagiarism. While educators can recommend that students pay more attention to the source in the first place, that wonât solve the problem entirely.
To encourage slow thinking when someone shares a fact theyâve read, heard, or seen somewhere, Hobbs suggests encouraging students to ask the person, âWhere did you hear that from?â in an attempt to connect the piece of information to its original source, instead of simply accepting it without question. Thereâs a big difference between something a student read in a New York Times article versus a conspiracy theory video on YouTube.
âItâs important for students to learn that these cognitive biases arenât things that we have to figure out on our ownâwe can help each other,â Hobbs says. âRely on other people to help you slow down by asking you questions about the basis of your beliefs, or how and why you came to have certain attitudes and values.â